Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Fire the lot of them


I’ve wanted to write a bit about how I think the Singapore Police Force has gotten just that little bit useless but just haven’t found the time to until today. A few events I’ve witnessed or personally experienced in the last few years have given me this impression and I will certainly describe them soon.
Right now however, I will relate the events of this afternoon.

Travelling along the PIE on our way back to the office, Joe and I saw a plume of smoke some distance ahead just about the same time cars started slowing down. Thinking it might be a fire, I pulled to the left lane and when Joe confirmed it was a car on fire, I got onto the emergency lane and drove up to a little less than 100 metres from a burning Volvo. A truck had stopped ahead of it and two people - who later turned out to be the driver and her son - were standing on the road shoulder looking on. I grabbed the two fire extinguishers I had in the boot, passed one to Joe and we ran up to the car.

As we passed the lady I ascertained no one was trapped in the car and that the fire services had been called.

I recall seeing one or two people, probably from the truck, in front of the car and I think they had an extinguisher with them. The flames were licking around the cracked grill and the gaps around the bonnet and the smoke was thick and a little acrid. I emptied my smaller extinguisher down low and at the base of the fire around the radiator grill but did nothing to stem the rapidly increasing inferno. Joe’s extinguisher, a little larger, was similarly emptied in seconds but the fire was by now raging under the bonnet.

About a minute or so had passed and with nothing but empty extinguishers in the car I ran back to see if there was anything else I could use in my boot.

A police patrol car arrived just then, crawling along the line separating the slow lane and the emergency lane. They must have been doing about 10 km/h and I waved frantically at them. As they drew abreast, I noticed the front passenger was on his walkie-talkie. I was screaming at them at this stage - obscenities were used liberally, loudly and with some gusto. I couldn’t believe these two cops were proceeding as if it was a Sunday School Parade. No sense of urgency, no rush, no apparent appreciation of the need for immediate action.

I ran past them back to the burning car just to see what else could be done. I left them rummaging in their boot… I have welder’s gloves in my car but I thought it best not to try and open anything up lest I unleash a hitherto oxygen-deprived beast.

At this point the cop who had been on the walkie talkie came up with a larger extinguisher and when he saw how large the flames had become, much to my astonishment he lay the extinguisher on the side of the road and proceeded to do other mysterious police duties. Like ask meaningless questions, talk more on his walkie talkie and walk up and down.

Around this time a motorbike-riding fire response officer came up, dismounted and began unravelling some strange contraption. This turned out to be a great device which seemed to shoot jets of compressed air out in order to starve the fire of oxygen.

As the evidently-trained authorities had arrived I took out my iPhone and started videotaping the next few minutes. Now watch the video and see for yourself why I would fire the lot of the police force.


At about 10 seconds, you see a couple of guys come up with yellow jackets and bearing extinguishers. No, not police nor firefighters. These two were from the official tow truck. They were obviously very panicky and tentative and discharged their extinguisher waaaayyy too far form the fire - someone should train these chaps I think. Whoever was in charge of training them should be fired too come to think of it.

Note how these guys are on the slow lane. Now, at this point, the traffic has not been blocked from this lane! Some idiotic driver in a world of his own and wondering why the left lane was so free and empty (and don’t we know there must be hundreds of drivers like this around?) could have barrelled along and run down these two Samaritans. Not to mention the one guy in uniform who seemed to know what he was doing.

The flames were way too big by this time of course and you can hear me say so in the video.
At this point what do you think the cops were doing? Directing traffic perhaps? Setting up warning signs? Well, from about 00:38 you can see for yourself.

And you can hear me incredulously suggesting they do something useful like ensuring traffic moves around smoothly and safely, and maybe ensuring there is space for the next lot of emergency vehicles to come in.

But no….. taking notes and checking with someone on the walkie talkie is a muuuuucccchhhhh better thing to do in an emergency.

As I am very pointed in my comments, I’ve thought it best to try and cover their identities hence the funny square in the video.

Yes, yes, at 1:00 I was making a note of the cop car number…. Incidentally you can see my car parked behind, with the boot lid up and the hazards flashing.

At about 1:10 you can hear the sirens of other response vehicles approaching. But no, they will have no cops to direct them in….

Instead they have a Land Transport Authority Officer (a Certis Cisco Officer you will note) pull up on his little Gilera 3-wheeler. A Rhino pulls up too - I presume the Rhino was travelling at the speed of the Gilera seeing as it appeared to have been escorted there by it. The firefighters spill out and although we later discover they pulled up too short, I think they did a decent job.

The second Rhino did better though I think.

Then a strange thing happens - at 2:13 the sirens get switched off. Is this standard procedure?

Considering this is a highway and there is traffic going past, and our two cops are still busy taking notes and talking on the walkie talkie, shouldn’t one siren be left on to alert cars? You hear me voice as much on 2:18.

The first Rhino is manoeuvred closer, the big engine begins to do what it does best, the LTA officer stands around relying the flashing lights of his Gilera to guide traffic along… At 2:35 you hear Joe hypothesising that the cops were waiting for the LTA officer or a Traffic Cop to direct traffic and you hear too my exasperated response saying the cops should have the training to do this.

At about 2:50 the mother of the driver and I start chatting. She too was puzzled why the first cop had not used his extinguisher or done more and had opined as much.

At 3:10 you see the LTA officer eschewing his more-visible and safer (considering the circumstances) helmet for a presumably comfier cap. Then at 3:15 you see there are now traffic cones laid out and cars are thus avoiding the area. What isn’t on the video is what I discovered later - the cones were not, as I had originally thought, placed by the cops, but by the tow truck guys. They also eventually moved their tow truck across the first two lanes to act as a stop and buffer in case someone came blindly barreling along.

What is also not shown on the video is our conversation with the LTA officer who came over to us and asked why we were there. Duh… I wished the lady all the best - she wanted my name but I thought that was not necessary and when she thanked us profusely I just told her to please help someone else if she were in our shoes and saw someone in need.

As for our two cops, I didn’t see them after one wandered off in the direction of the traffic cones.
I’m still both astounded and pissed off. It occurs to me now too that I’d heard neither of the cops ask the first question I’d asked the lady ‘Is there anybody trapped inside?’

10 comments:

  1. That's pretty public spirited of you. I would think that it will cost you a bit to refill the extinguishers, so well done. I get the feeling that the police may have been trained years ago at the academy and haven't had to use their training since then. Perhaps they had a C- average when they were assessed.

    Cheers, Peter Boudville

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes your public spirited act went well in the beginning but get over-reacted subsequently. You should have leave it to the cop to do whatever they should, and not passing comment and suggestion as if you knows better, especially while they were discharging their duty.

    Have you ever come to your mind that what if someone gets too close to the fire and gets hurt?

    Please do not get too excited whenever you come across incident like this, or you may end up making thing difficult and not helping.

    Good luck.....

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks guys for your brave and courageous help. I'm the driver of the brunt volvo. Your assistance in helping to put out the fire is highly appreciated.
    Even public servant like the SSgt that came and arrive at the scene first, don't even bother to help when he has brought a fire extinguisher with him.
    Thanks a million guys, you made a great-spirited Singapore whom will care and provide your assistance to other fellow citizens.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Winston,
    Glad to have been able to try and help even if we were ultimately not successful. As I mentioned yesterday, the important thing is no one was hurt. Also so very happy to hear you will reach out to help others when you see someone in need. That really is the most important thing. Be well, be safe. My best wishes to your Mum too.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Winston

    My sympathies for the loss of your car, and thankfulness no one got hurt.

    Any idea or clue why the car could suddenly catch fire like that?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Frankly, I'm clueless of the cause, as it's just one of the leisure cars my family owned and shared driving in and I'm usually overseas. May be it's just an unluckily day and a sour lemon.
    It all started out when the the car can't accelerate and can't brake, thus I drive it onto the road shoulder and brake it with the hand brake. The next moment, flames and smokes started to appear and the fire just started like this.
    Very surprising and unexpected for a Volvo, of which is well maintained and completely original from the factory.
    Anyway, it's just great that every one is safe and no one is hurt during the incident.
    In addition, it's very interesting to see the 'work' from the public servants. I would say the Fire-fighting team and members did a great job despite the huge flames from the car, but the reaction and professionalism of the first policeman whom arrive (SSgt) at the scene first is very much disappointing.

    ReplyDelete
  7. https://www.facebook.com/#!/sgcarmart/posts/245222492204325?notif_t=like

    most people feels otherwise about the comments posted here...

    ReplyDelete
  8. Redbeanmilk - I was wondering why the post had so many views suddenly. Ha ha it's OK - the internet is all about people voicing their opinion and not everyone needs to agree with what we saw that day. It doesn't matter a bit that we used dry powder extinguishers, or that we aimed at the base of the fire, or that the cops really didn't do anything (ask Winston, whose car was on fire), or that the the tow truck people were standing in between the slow and middle lanes in obvious danger, or that it was the tow truck people who eventually put cones out, or... It really doesn't matter because people will have the opinions they want to have, regardless. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Well...

    If your multiple fire extinguishers didn't help, the cop car's fire extinguisher wouldn't help better either. Looking at the fire, it may have been good judgment to leave it to the red rhino (the specialists).

    I suppose it would not have been better if the cops arrive, used their small extinguisher, didn't put out the fire, run around frantically (cos there is nothing much more they can do), look panicky.

    I sympathise with the lost of the car, and the police officers could have at least put some effort to "look" like they had some urgency - It would at least made on-lookers feel much better (though they wouldn't have been in a position to provide much help anyway).

    Let's be grateful for a few things:

    1. Cops arrived fairly quickly (could have spend their time catching criminals elsewhere)
    2. At least 5 "government people" were despatched to the scene. General tax-payers costs (of course, including the car owner). They could have just dispatched the red rhino - it is, after all, a private affair.

    And I think most importantly - no one was injured (traumatised certainly). I suppose the cops would have ascertained first thing whether anyone was injured. If they didn't, they should surely be fired. Lost of the car i painful, but I am glad all parties came out safe.

    Let's not jump at the opportunity to point fingers. There are underlying "rules of operation" which we may or may not know. Be glad that those who helped in one way or another did so - whichever speed they did it at.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The best thing for that first policeman at the scene to do is to report back to get the relevant people in, in this case the ones specialised in putting out fire/managing traffic. Trying to be the sole hero putting out fire with his own fire extinguisher when in his judgetment (and mine honestly) is of no use would be wasting time and be the most useless thing to do.

    While you are to be commended on being helpful, passing out those disparaging remarks at the officers at duty is most disrepectful, arrogant and ultimately serve only to harm rather than help the situation.

    ReplyDelete